Christmas Mystery Advent Calendar 2026, 24 Day Santa Mystery, Who Stole Santa's Presents

My kids are completely into this! They keep talking about who they think stole Santa’s presents and changing their guesses as new clues come out. It’s been a really fun way to count down to Christmas and definitely more exciting than the usual advent calendar.

My kids absolutely love this! Instead of just opening a door and getting a treat, they actually sit together and try to figure out what each new clue means. The little characters and mystery pieces are adorable too. They’ve already started arguing over who they think stole Santa’s presents 😂 Such a fun way to count down to Christmas.

This is such a cute idea for an advent calendar! Every day gives us another piece of the mystery and my kids are already making wild guesses about who took Santa’s presents. The penguin is their favorite so far. They actually look forward to solving the clue together each evening.

This has quickly become part of our morning routine. Open the day, look at the new piece, read the clue, then everyone makes their guess. Even the adults have gotten competitive about solving it. Definitely doing another mystery calendar next year!

We’ve done chocolate calendars for years and wanted something different this Christmas. This one is so much more interactive. The mystery gives the kids something to talk about every day, and the little pieces are adorable too.

I wasn’t sure how long this would hold their attention, but they’re genuinely excited for the next clue every morning. They compare their guesses and keep changing their minds about who did it 😂 Such a fun December activity.

My kids are obsessed with mysteries, so this was an instant hit. They love getting a new clue each day and trying to figure out who stole Santa’s presents. It makes the countdown to Christmas so much more exciting!

Such a creative concept. I bought it because I wanted an advent calendar that felt like an actual activity, and this was exactly what I was looking for. The Santa mystery is cute, festive and easy for the whole family to enjoy together.

He is taking this VERY seriously 😂 He has his own list of suspects and keeps going back through the previous clues. I love that it gives him something fun to think about instead of just opening a piece of candy every morning.

We open ours after dinner and everyone gets to make a guess about the mystery. It only takes a few minutes, but it’s become one of my favorite little parts of December. The kids are determined to find out who stole Santa’s presents before day 24!